The complete list of all picks!
| Show Number | Date | Picks- Devon | Picks -Andy | |
| Episode 24 | 2/13/2019 | NA | Simic Ascendency, Teysa Karlov, Gutterbones | |
| Episode 23 | 2/3/2019 | Gaddock Teeg | Cindervines, Nikya of the Old Ways, Pestilent Spirit | |
| Episode 22 | 1/30/2019 | Electrodominance, Tithe Taker | Sphinx of Foresight, Wilderness Reclaimation, Revival//Revenge | |
| Episode 20 | 1/16/2019 | Scapeshift, Crucible of Worlds | NA | |
| Episode 16 | 12/17/2018 | Old-Growth Dryad, Two-Headed Giant, Grand Warlord Radha | Sarkhan's Unsealing, Deathgorger Scavenger, Territorial Allosaurus | |
| Episode 15 | 12/10/2018 | Divine Visitation, Isareth, the Awakener | Ashes of the Abhorent, Bloodcrazed Paladin | |
| Episode 14 | 12/5/2018 | Arguil's Bloodfast, Kitesail Freebooter, Legion Warboss (Dragonskull summit) | Sword Point Diplomacy, Tomb Robber, Angrath - The Flame-Chained | |
| Episode 13 | 11/28/2018 | Hinterland Harbor, Hadana's Climb | Kopala, Warden of the Waves, Beast Whisperer | |
| Episode 12 | 11/16/2018 | Goreclaw, Terror of Qal Sisma | Azor, the Lawbringer | |
| Episode 11 | 11/12/2018 | Demon of Catatrophes, Dragon's hoard | Venerated Loxodon, Haazda Marshall | |
| Episode 10 | 11/7/2018 | Duplicant (revisited Soul of New Phyrexia) | Unclaimed Territory, Silent Gravestone | |
| Episode 9 | 10/30/2018 | Mimic Vat, Abyssal Persecuter | Baird, Steward of Argive, Hadana's Climb | |
| Episode 8 | 10/21/2018 | Hinterland Harbor, Rootbound Crag | Swiftblade Vindicator | |
| Episode 7 | 10/14/2018 | Helm of the Host, Detection Tower | Bounty Hunter. Isolate, infernal reckoning | |
| Episode 6 | 10/8/2018 | Cabal Stronghold, Conqueror's Flag, reefwurm | Omnispell Adept, connive/concoct, Deafing Clarion | |
| Episode 5 | 10/1/2018 | Kor Spirit Dance, Vindicate, Iconic Master Box | Saheeli, Soul Scar Mage, Mazes End | |
| Episode 4 | 9/27/2018 | Beast Within, Eidulon, Regrowth | Fatal Push, Annointed Procession, Scrap Trawler | |
| Episode 3 | 9/10/2018 | Samut the Tested, Dovin Bond, Memory Plunder | Lilana's Contract, Magistrate's Scepter, Skilled Animator | |
| Episode 2 | 9/10/2018 | Glimpse of the Unthinkable, Inspiring Vantage/Concealed Courtyard, Box of Iconic Master | Metamorphic Alteration, Goblin Trashmaster, Doublecast |